April 28, 2008

Irish Psychiatrist Slams ECT

I've not written about ECT in ages, so it was nice to see a piece in Ireland's Independent yesterday wherein an Irish psychiatrist slammed the use of ECT:

"Dr Michael Corry, consultant psychiatrist at the Institute of Psychosocial Medicine, contends that the state of confusion, sometimes tinged with a mild euphoria, that is regularly encountered in the aftermath of some types of head injuries, temporarily obscures the patient's original symptoms, which is then erroneously classified by psychiatrists as an 'improvement.'

"'The fact that these results wear off is underlined by the reality that some patients have literally had hundreds of shocks. Why is this terrible and devastating human rights abuse allowed to go on?' he asks.

"Dr Corry is leading the Irish campaign to abolish ECT. 'It's irrational, archaic and barbaric it has no place in the 21st century,' he says.

"'It is universally agreed that the occurrence of seizures in a patient is always harmful to their brain. Within neurology as a speciality, every effort is made to prevent seizures but, incredibly, psychiatry stands out as the only branch of medicine that specialises in deliberately causing seizures.'"

Separately, the paper reports on a former ECT patient who is campaigning to end the use of the procedure.

My own view is that I am against ECT, even though doctors I know and respect believe in the procedure. For whatever reason, I cannot wrap my mind around shocking someone's brain and I have seen too many patients experience bad outcomes from the procedure, chief among them Ernest Hemingway who claimed that the procedure "put me out of business."

I am also against the forced use of ECT on any human being. If someone wants to opt for the procedure, go right ahead. And, good luck to them.

Posted by Philip Dawdy at April 28, 2008 12:03 AM
StumbleUpon Toolbar del.icio.us Digg it reddit
Comments

A *psychiatrist* asks "Why is this terrible and devastating human rights abuse allowed to go on?"!!!

Of interest: "I am also against the forced use of ECT on any human being." Which forced psychiatric procedures (treatments?) are you not against?

Posted by: Ted at April 28, 2008 05:27 AM

News for those in Canada, living near Ottawa.
**********************************

Mother's Day Event - Demonstration Against Electroshock
"Stop Shocking our Mothers and Grandmother's"
May ll, 2008, Sunday
Ottawa, Ontario, Canada
Parliament Hill on Wellington Street
Meet at the Centennial Flame
1 to 4 p.m.
--------------------------------------
We hope as many groups and people can come to the protest. Please spread this info far and wide.

50% of ECT is given to women over 60 years of age.

ECT always causes brain damage. The ICBE deems ECT as unethical, inhumane, barbaric and torture. ECT is an atrocity and it is a crime against
humanity and ECT must end now.

The ICBE is asking for a moratorium on the use of electroshock in Canada.

The ICBE is presently lobbying all politicians in Canada regarding this issue.

ECT should have been banned many years ago as there are many reports and studies that prove that ECT always causes brain damage.

Read the article by American psychiatrist Dr. Peter R. Breggin called "Disturbing News for Patients and Shock Doctors Alike" in which Dr. Breggin writes about a study that proves that ECT always causes brain damage.
See the full text of this article at this link:

huffingtonpost.com/dr-peter-breggin/disturbing-news-for-patie_b_44734.html

Sue Clark-Wittenberg, Director of the ICBE had ECT given to her against her
will at the age of l7 years old in 1973 at the Brockville Psychiatric Hospital.
On her 5th ECT, her heart stopped and she had to be revived. She suffers from
permanent memory loss and has difficulty learning new things as a result of having ECT.

Sue's mom Theresa also had ECT given to her at the Ottawa Civic Hospital in the 1970s.

The statistics for ECTs given yearly are:

14,000 ECTs given yearly in Ontario, Canada
46,000 ECTs given in British Columbia, Canada in the past 5 years
USA - 100,000 Americans get ECT yearly, since 1940 when ECT was introduced
over 6 million Americans have had ECT
UK - 50,000 ECTs given yearly
Worldwide - 1 to 2 Million people get ECT yearly.

Sue says "no one should ever have to go through what I did", let's end this atrocity now".

Let's all help to end ECT today. Your voice counts. Send a letter to your politician today and tell them to stop ECT now.

Don Weitz from Toronto who is an anti-ECT activist and author and human rights activist has confirmed he will be at the protest.

The ICBE will be making the Mother's Day Event an annual event every year.

Posted by: mark p.s. at April 28, 2008 01:02 PM

ECT is certainly not without its risks, but what medical procedure is?

ECT's effectiveness data is pretty strong - on par with 3-vessel CABG. If we want to get rid of ECT, let's come up with some non-shit medical treatments, huh?

And its brutality? Is electroshock really more brutal than getting your chest cracked with a bone-saw and rib-spreader?

ECT is the only medical procedure that I know of in my home state of Texas that a family member can't consent me for if I'm unable to consent for myself - so if I'm catatonic, failing to respond to meds, and unable to consent to ECT, I can't have access to the gold-standard treatment?

WTF?

Posted by: OllieC at April 28, 2008 07:48 PM

I really don't know enough about ECT to comment on whether or not it is indeed "a holocaust of the brain" and "a brutal final solution". But as far as I can tell from the article (which I think was meant to be favorable), Dr. Corry has a big ideological ax to grind, as well as a penchant for woolly thinking and tasteless, overblown rhetoric. I hope this isn't all the anti-ECT cause has to offer, because if so, no wonder it isn't getting anywhere.

Posted by: Garth at April 28, 2008 08:47 PM

Ollie, you can always move to New York. Being in Texas myself, I thank my lucky stars I was not forced to have this gold-standard treatment. I was told ECT was my only hope, and thank god I was able to say hell no. I've been off all psych meds almost 6 years now. I guess I wasn't such a hopeless case after all.

Posted by: Lisa at April 29, 2008 07:31 AM

I have personally met Michael Corry...
He is a beacon of compassion and hope for Mental health rights in Ireland..
He is a great man, very compassionate and humanist in his approach to the mind..
Great to see him getting the attention he deserves..
Good on ya Mr Corry..
:)

Posted by: truthman30 at April 29, 2008 11:11 AM

Ollie, Texas does recognize psychiatric advance directives, in which you can pre-consent to ECT.

Posted by: Anne at May 13, 2008 07:46 AM

Please contact me as I am at high risk in bC however Post MVA head trama they still have me down as a mental case as a result of ECT in 60s in Toronto. I require medical but fear hospital as health Canada have me profieled as does rcmp it is unsafe for seniors out here with a lable . Thank God for folks like us my fighting against the system has me labled as defient and rebelous . I attended the conference long time ago OUR TURN which was held in Quebec. I need help in BC do you know where I can get that support. Thanks pals see ya god bless all of us. ! Irene

Posted by: irene carlson at September 23, 2008 11:55 PM

you must punish all medically registered people for delivery of any kind of forced treatment. if you do not start now it will never end. you must understand that they do not have any comprehension of patient rights other than doctoring their bodies at the least expense to medical insurance. all people who have participated in forced treatment must be punished in whatever way is possible. it is not necesary to do this legally. in fact it is impossible. do not complain -- act. do not converse with medical people. they are trained and have absolutely no sympathy or restraint against treating patients. ACT NOW. punish them in any way you can. NO MERCY. I recommend you act alone. it is not possible to do this with any other persons trust. ACT NOW. do not allow your body to be destroyed by ect. if you can not revenge yourself. revenge someone else. do not ask or expect any reward. no one can possibly understand the pervesion of a medical person's rape on a patients mind and body. patients who undergo this procedure have no understanding of how perverse it is and should not be consulted. ACT on your own and do not bother to leave any explanation of your behaviour. NO ONE is capable of understanding it. ACT NOW and punish them for the extreme rape of your mind and body. fear nothing, act now, no mercy!

Posted by: asdf at January 20, 2009 10:52 AM
Post a comment









Remember personal info?






pic1.jpg

Patient Blogs. Sites.
Doctor Blogs. Sites.
Activists. News.
Social Networking. Forums.
Science. Big Pharma. Ethics.
Current Affairs
Seattle Stuff
Smoking. Stuff.

Info
About Furious Seasons
Email
Other Articles
ZYPREXA Documents
Alt ZYPREXA Documents Source
Blakemore-Brown Transcript

 Subscribe in a reader

Search


Recent Entries
$99 Left
$114 To Go
Winter Fundraiser, $134 To Go, Final Day
Ruth Lilly, Eli Lilly Heiress, Prozac Beneficiary Dies At 94
Winter Fundraiser, Final Day, Less Than $200 To Go
UCLA Psychiatrist Criticizes DSM-5
Winter Fundraiser, Barely $200 To Go
Most Popular Posts Of 2009
Winter Fundraiser, Less Than $300 Left, Let's Wrap It Up
Senate Health Care Bill Contains $1.25 Billion Gift To Sen. Stabenow
Travel Day, Comment Approval May Be Intermittent
Winter Fundraiser, Close But Stalled
Senate Health Care Reform Bill Contains Controversial MOTHERS Act, Abortion Study
Adult ADHD And Sleep Problems
Vic Chesnutt Dead At 45, Possible Suicide
Recent Comments

asdf on Irish Psychiatrist Slams ECT

irene carlson on Irish Psychiatrist Slams ECT

Anne on Irish Psychiatrist Slams ECT

truthman30 on Irish Psychiatrist Slams ECT

Lisa on Irish Psychiatrist Slams ECT

Garth on Irish Psychiatrist Slams ECT

OllieC on Irish Psychiatrist Slams ECT

mark p.s. on Irish Psychiatrist Slams ECT

Ted on Irish Psychiatrist Slams ECT

Archives
December 2009
November 2009
October 2009
September 2009
August 2009
July 2009
June 2009
May 2009
April 2009
March 2009
February 2009
January 2009
December 2008
November 2008
October 2008
September 2008
August 2008
July 2008
June 2008
May 2008
April 2008
March 2008
February 2008
January 2008
December 2007
November 2007
October 2007
September 2007
August 2007
July 2007
June 2007
May 2007
April 2007
March 2007
February 2007
January 2007
December 2006
November 2006
October 2006
September 2006
August 2006
July 2006
June 2006
May 2006
April 2006
March 2006
February 2006
January 2006
December 2005
November 2005
October 2005
September 2005
Resources
Mental Health America
National Alliance on Mental Illness
Depression and Bipolar Support Alliance
National Institute of Mental Health
McMan Web
Powered by
Movable Type 3.2