October 05, 2006All Bipolar, All The TimeToday is National Depression Screening Day and bipolar disorder screening is being tossed in as well, all of it brought to you by NAMI and Screening for Mental Health, Inc. The latter is run by a bunch of psych docs at Harvard. NAMI takes gobs of money from pharma companies. Just putting some perspective on all this. Perhaps, I am too much of a skeptic today, but there's something that concerns me about all the mental health screening going on. Maybe it's because I remember the dark old days of the early-90s, when depression and bipolar disroder were not publicly discussed, or if they were in whispered tones. Now, it's everywhere. If there's one constant in American culture, it's that when we go after something, when we buy into a paradigm, we go whole hog, sometimes to our detriment and sometimes to our benefit. I am not sure why that makes me skeptical, but there is a bit of the "mental illness is fashionable" business going on here that makes me go "Hmmm." I guess it's because I was recently thinking through an experience a friend of mine had a couple of years ago. She's a single mom, raising two kids on a very limited income, as her ex is a dead beat dad. Her daughter, nine at the time, was having a bit of trouble at school—irritable, not paying attention, bored off her ass and so on. I also knew her to be a stunning artist—a natural—for someone so young. So her mom gets dragged into school for a parent-teacher conference. Short story: the teacher spends about half the conference trying to convince the mom that her kid is depressed, should be put on medication (we're talking about a nine-year-old for God's sake) and that mom is being a bad parent if she doesn't follow through. Teacher claims she'd screened the kid by asking her questions and so on. Is anyone else bothered by that process? I cannot quite put my finger on why I am, but I am sure bothered by teachers playing diagnostician and then lecturing the parents. I have no problem with a teacher reporting obvious signs of mental illness or behavioral maladies to parents, nurses and so on. But it does seem to me that there a lot of ideologically-based diagnosing going on. Well, two years later, kiddo is doing fine. No meds, no depression, just your typical 11-year-old behavior. BTW, a handy little press release from NAMI on the screening stuff states that there are now 10 million bipolars in America. I don't question that number, but across that number of people there is a wide range of severities of the illness, something that often gets lost in discussions of mental health. The NAMI release stresses that 80 percent of diagnosed bipolars have "treatment success." That claim is oddly high, and is the same exact number that the fine folks at TAC cite. Guess it depends on how you define success. Anyhow, all of this is just me engaging in early morning skepticism, nothing more. Posted by Philip Dawdy at October 5, 2006 08:36 AM
del.icio.us
Digg it
reddit
Comments
I've come to the conclusion that no one is real. Except me. It's kind of sad becuase that means that I'm all alone in the world, but it's so, so true: No one is real except me. My doctor's not real; Philip is not real; my mentor for my scholarship is not real -- no one. It's sad but true. Posted by: Gwen at October 5, 2006 10:36 AMYou know, everyone exhibits symptoms of mental illness. Hell, who among us hasn't demonstrated the classically OCD behavior of having to check the door a few times because we aren't sure if we locked it or not? These screenings seem like nothing more than a crass attempt by Big Pharma to drum up new customers by selling them more shit that they don't need instead of a doctor telling them to actually confront and deal with their problems in an emotionally healthy and productive way instead of repressing the shit until it boils up inside them and manifests itself in self-destructive behaviors. Whew. Looks like I can still bust out a one-minute tirade when called for. Posted by: Puckett at October 5, 2006 04:39 PMI got a mild case of Seritonin Syndrome. Anyone ever hear of it? It's where you get akasthesia and feel neausous and weak, and I read that some people have to be hospitlaized and even die from it. My gosh, I felt so bad a couple of days ago that I thought I was going to have to take a medical leave of absence for this quarter. But then my doctor gave me something to counteract it -- so now I'm all better! It feels good to feel good. NEVER play with your meds during school!!! Posted by: Gwen at October 5, 2006 08:52 PMI had this problem with my daughter when she was 11 yrs old. Overzealous wanne-be mental health screener-teacher told me she was suicidal because she was looking down from a balcony. The staff does, behind parents backs, bitch and complain about kids on meds and on bad days "did they take them?". I have the unfortunate ability to hear this bullshit per my job and those teaachers have no idea what this is like. I myself, have been questioned over and over on days my daughter was raging out of control on Zoloft, if she took her meds that day, when they called me to pick her up. YES Don't get me started. Mental health professionals are not the same as teachers and so on. Fine lines are walked, by sending teachers to classes for 3 hours a year to "learn the signs". Hell some pdocs don't know the signs. Posted by: Stephany at October 5, 2006 09:56 PMI was having an appointment with my scholarship advisor, and of course, she knows all about how I have schziophrenia and how I write a lot about mental illness and such. Anyway, she was reading my proposal, and then we both hear some person outside her office say "That's totally insane!" My advisor then smiles, looks up, and asks me, "Does that ever offend you?" I smile too. "No," I respond. "When people say that kind of thing, they're not -- at least most of the time -- trying to be offensive. It's just how English coversation has evolved." "Good to hear," she says. And then goes back to reading my paper. Does anyone anyone feel differently than I do? Posted by: Gwen at October 6, 2006 11:09 AMI haven't experienced this problem myself but can see your point. On the other hand, I wish someone would have said to my parents, "Your daughter needs help", because maybe I wouldn't have had to go through twenty-eight years of hell before I was diagnosed and properly treated. I have all this homework to do, and all these articles to write, and I'm feeling a little bit overwhelmed. Stop the madness! And this site is a HUGE distraction. I should really stop reading and writing on this thing when I have work to do. Man, I feel really overwhemled. And I have a problem with realness right now. Anyway, I just need to shut up and do this freakin work of mine! Posted by: Gwen at October 7, 2006 11:27 AMThe trendiness of mental illness makes me sick. Woody Allen nailbiters, so harmful to the credibility of people who live with severe and persistent mental illness. Jeff, my soul mate has bi-polar, the extent of which few can imagine, and he is stuck right now in a psych ward because effin NAMI got to his family and they all convinced Jeff to make his dad power of attorney. So dad put him in the state hospital indefinitely, and has agreed to an infantilizing lifestyle program of enrichment or some shit a degree above basket-weaving, and of course he agrees to go back on Lithium, which negates his agency even more. I could just cry. My friend Jeff is one of the archetypal madmen the poets wrote about, the most perceptive human being I've ever known, but when he goes mad it's all the way, and the depressions nearly kill him, and now he's lost his self-determination. He never asked for any of it, so yeah, the fashionable side of mental illness is a puzzler, in light of what mental illness does to an actual sufferer. Also, I pimped Furious Seasons at a B-list lefty blog today, which linked to some story you did on Star Wars. Who loves ya baby? Posted by: flawedplan at October 9, 2006 12:23 PMRE: NAMI. This was my constant struggle. My daughter sought treatment voluntarily, and ended up part of the court system, due to insurance cap on inpatient running out. Being in mental health court for nearly a year on a weekly basis, I would avoid the traditional waiting area for parents and caregivers. I was so tired of hearing old women drone on and on about how "long I have been doing this". I needed help from the people helping my daughter and that was to speak freely with me, as a parent of a legal adult, their hands were tied, and I never wanted a guardianship. I never wanted to feel like I owned someone, or remove a freedom, I can tell everyone, that NAMI pushes for this type of thing. I am not saying they cannot be support to those who need it, but it just is not my cup of tea. What I wanted to say to those women, who obviously walked the road to helping their adult children longer than I have done...was "why havent you done something to change this system?". My goal, after seeing this defunct, under-funded and inadequate system of taking care of mentally ill people in our country, is to change it for the better...to make it easier on those who will follow our trails. I feel those women were of course there out of love for their children, not questioning this at all, so was I. But the sitting down and whining part: Change this.
It was horrible, because, yes, the brilliant mind, unable to work, or function, reduced in her case to shakily putting together bead bracelets...broke my heart. The word suffer barely describes it. Take care and don't give up hope. -Stephany Posted by: Stephany at October 10, 2006 08:23 AMHere are the questions developed by "TeenScreen" (classroom mental health screenings that are increasingly common and at the center of Bush's freedom task force on mental illness) to weed out mentally ill youngsters. The people who developed these tests must have COMPLETELY forgotten what it feels like to be 13. I don't know a 13 year old who would not answer "Yes" to ALL of these questions: Think back to your childhood and remember... 1) Did you ever have a song stuck in your head and you just couldn't stop "singing" it? Did it ever last for days? Did you ever try to think of something else? 2) Was there ever a time you didn't feel like playing outside or couldn't find anything to do? ("Mom! I'm bored!, There's NOTHING to do!") 3) Were you ever nervous or anxious when you knew you had to give a presentation in front of the whole class? 4) Did you ever worry before taking a test and then during the test check and recheck your answers? 5) Did you ever want to sleep in until noon? 6) Did your parents ever get worried about you for any reason?
When hanging with my Grandmother, anyone dare to say "Im bored" got you a history lesson, complete with a globe, a seashell from a place she found it, such as Fiji, or a walk in the desert where she lived for plant indentification lectures. The best thing she ever talk me was the best things in life are free.
She was an avid non-medications person. When a 11 yr old comes to you sobbing she has (severe) homicidal thoughts, you take some sort of action. That action of mine got her into where I thought she should go. (a psych) It has been hard to maintain internal respect for any psychiatrist after what has happened to my daughter on medications. All mental illness aside, her body is trashed, and her childhood ruined. Outwardly, I respect them, treat them with dignity, that I expect returned, and never let them get away without an indepth discussion. Now they are getting lessons from me on how CLozaril works in the mind and body, and yep, Ive basically walked in the door and said, here is the information you need (again). One doc appreciates all of my information and likes to hear the anecdotal stories, for which he will benefit. He is smart to listen to me. Most won't.
Though I fought vigorously to open discussion re: side effects etc. it fell on deaf ears. It wasnt until what I had been saying since 2001 ended up in a FDA warning re: antidepressants, that the docs perked up when they heard me talk. I think their is some respect there the docs have for me, but that's not what I need, I needed them to hear my words yeaars earlier. Personal experiences in my life when for instance someone blamed my vocal advocacy for my daughter as being "where she is now" (in hospitals)sent me into a tailspin of guilt, depression, then insomnia, and sealed the deal with mania out of control. It is a contradiction to have these 2 paths run parallel in your mind, when being a Mother and wanting to keep your child well, safe and happy and blaming yourself for trying to keep your child well, safe and happy. Get it? To be a patient, and a Mother of 2 patients...shit. Try and walk in those shoes. |
Patient Blogs. Sites.
The Trouble With Spikol
Icarus Project Blog John's Bipolar Stories Seroxat (Paxil) Sufferers Stand Up! Seroxat (Paxil) Secrets The Bipolar View Writhe Safely soulful sepulcher Electro Boy Spiritual Emergency Mental Nurse Deborah Gray Mental Mommy The Splintered Mind bipolar.and.me Nurse Ratched Psych Person Trick Cycling for Beginners depression introspection Salted Lithium Living With A Purple Dog Polar Trippin' Mercurial Scribe Bipolar Chicks Blogging Bipolar Blast Off Label Jung At Heart Graphic Truth Joysoup Apesma's Lament Soapy Water Outlaw Psychiatry Empirical Insanity Patient Anonymous Beyond Blue Psych Survivor Postpartum Progress The Happiness Project Finding Optimism The Gimp Parade Midlife and Treachery Secret Life of a Manic-Depressive Psych Tech Going Through Hell
Doctor Blogs. Sites.
Clinical Psych
World of Psychology CorePsych The Last Psychiatrist Carlat Report Blog Intueri Emotional Well-Being Scientific Misconduct Aaron Beck Cognitive Therapy Today Treatment Online Shrink Rap David Healy Dr. Dork NHS Blog Doctor Dr. X's Free Associations Dr. Sanity Anxious Mind Everyone Needs Therapy Counselling Resource
Activists. News.
Charlottesville Prejudice Watch
The Icarus Project MindFreedom AHRP Blog SSRI Stories Healthy Skepticism Psych Rights Treatment Advocacy Center Peter Breggin Schizophrenia News eDrugSearch Blog Nuts R Us News Disapedia WSJ Health Blog
Social Networking. Forums.
Mood Garden
Paxil Progress Crazy Boards Forums Psych Central Forums Icarus Project Forums DepressionTribe MySpace Bipolar Group Bipolar World Pendulum.org Bipolar Planet About.com Bipolar
Science. Big Pharma. Ethics.
PharmaLot
Pharma Gossip Science Blogs Mind Hacks GoozNews Integrity in Science Neurophilospohy bioethics.net Drug Wonks Pharma Marketing Blog Pharma's Cutting Edge On Pharma Health Care Renewal
Current Affairs
Buzz Machine
To The People Andrew Sullivan Michelle Malkin Daily Kos Reason's Hit&Run The Agitator Press Think Jim Romenesko Rough Type Gawker The Graphic Truth Tail Rank Huffington Post Instapundit Little Green Footballs Talking Points Memo MoJo Blog
Seattle Stuff
Smoking. Stuff.
|

