May 15, 2006Pete Earley's Op-Ed Blasts Around The CountryIn an earlier post today, I referenced Pete Earley's op-ed from the May 12 Washington Post. It is now being picked up in slightly revised form by papers all over the country. Here's one example. By Google News's count, it has been picked up 181 times. Given how wildly distorted his op-ed was (the mentally-ill are all dangerous and must be forcibly treated, etc.), I hope to get the opportunity to answer him fully in the pages of the WaPost. If I do, it will be interesting to see how many papers pick it up. I don't question Earley's good intentions in arguing for accessible treatment for the most seriously mentally-ill (an argument I've been advancing in print for two years now), but he's making the classic mistake of assuming that psych meds work all the time and in all places and are great for long-term use. For people like him, the civil liberties of the mentally-ill aren't that important. It's funny how often that argument is advanced by parents of the mentally-ill, who seem to be perfectly fine with the idea of their offspring being turned into zombies. People have got to want treatment for treatment to work. What's more I am still deeply suspicious of some of the statistics he uses. More to come. Posted by Philip Dawdy at May 15, 2006 12:21 PM
del.icio.us
Digg it
reddit
Comments
This must be a generalized statement re: parents. When I saw my daughter become a zombie on meds I fought to get them adjusted. I supported her wish to go off of meds, and once back on them, she was a leaning shuffling, drooling zombie, I once again spoke up, asked questions, and demanded the med in question be reduced, and the zombie state diminished. She has been the most aggressive on medications. Off the meds, during the 'wash' she was aggressive, but nothing I couldnt deal with, yet she ripped her hair out and screamed to help her. I did. She is probably one of those 1 in thousands cases that no one wants to talk about, no one wants to figure out. Not all parents fall into the categories placed here. I am not a pity party, and I am not asking for help. I want intellectual discussion based on fact. Who walks in the NAMI walk? the survivors? or the survivors? I refuse to walk and be thought of as a pity party by a line that appears to be drawn further into the sand. Come on. We know injustice when we see it. We know what is right and what is wrong. Extreme cases require extreme care. That is the point. Generalizing parents and survivors fuels the division that I thought no one wants in this arena. There is a lot of bullshit out there in the form of written materials, people can take some and leave some. Smart people disregard the crap. I do. I want to know the real story. By real people. Speak up, and stop holding back. Posted by: Stephany at May 15, 2006 05:21 PMThis study appears to be more reasonable. It notes: In 2005, a Canadian journal published a review of all relevant past research on risk assessment for violence among people with mental illness. One dominating theme of the review was that violence can be much more accurately predicted by attending to non-mental health variables compared to mental health factors. These variables include age, gender, socioeconomic status, education, and environment. Additionally, a history of violence is a much stronger predictor of future violence than any mental health-related variables. [...] As psychiatric hospitals continue to downsize, the growing number of people with mental illness living in the community has raised concerns about public safety. However, when the types of crime committed by people with mental disorders are examined, violence is not at the top. A 2005 study included an inventory of the types of crimes committed by patients with schizophrenia. Of the 23% who had criminal records, two thirds had committed crimes against property, and two thirds had committed traffic law violations. Violent crimes had been committed by less than a quarter of those with criminal records — less than six per cent of the total patient population. Source: http://www.heretohelp.bc.ca/publications/factsheets/violence.shtml |
Patient Blogs. Sites.
The Trouble With Spikol
Icarus Project Blog John's Bipolar Stories Seroxat (Paxil) Sufferers Stand Up! Seroxat (Paxil) Secrets The Bipolar View Writhe Safely soulful sepulcher Electro Boy Spiritual Emergency Mental Nurse Deborah Gray Mental Mommy The Splintered Mind bipolar.and.me Nurse Ratched Psych Person Trick Cycling for Beginners depression introspection Salted Lithium Living With A Purple Dog Polar Trippin' Mercurial Scribe Bipolar Chicks Blogging Bipolar Blast Off Label Jung At Heart Graphic Truth Joysoup Apesma's Lament Soapy Water Outlaw Psychiatry Empirical Insanity Patient Anonymous Beyond Blue Psych Survivor Postpartum Progress The Happiness Project Finding Optimism The Gimp Parade Midlife and Treachery Secret Life of a Manic-Depressive Psych Tech Going Through Hell
Doctor Blogs. Sites.
Clinical Psych
World of Psychology CorePsych The Last Psychiatrist Carlat Report Blog Intueri Emotional Well-Being Scientific Misconduct Aaron Beck Cognitive Therapy Today Treatment Online Shrink Rap David Healy Dr. Dork NHS Blog Doctor Dr. X's Free Associations Dr. Sanity Anxious Mind Everyone Needs Therapy Counselling Resource
Activists. News.
Charlottesville Prejudice Watch
The Icarus Project MindFreedom AHRP Blog SSRI Stories Healthy Skepticism Psych Rights Treatment Advocacy Center Peter Breggin Schizophrenia News eDrugSearch Blog Nuts R Us News Disapedia WSJ Health Blog
Social Networking. Forums.
Mood Garden
Paxil Progress Crazy Boards Forums Psych Central Forums Icarus Project Forums DepressionTribe MySpace Bipolar Group Bipolar World Pendulum.org Bipolar Planet About.com Bipolar
Science. Big Pharma. Ethics.
PharmaLot
Pharma Gossip Science Blogs Mind Hacks GoozNews Integrity in Science Neurophilospohy bioethics.net Drug Wonks Pharma Marketing Blog Pharma's Cutting Edge On Pharma Health Care Renewal
Current Affairs
Buzz Machine
To The People Andrew Sullivan Michelle Malkin Daily Kos Reason's Hit&Run The Agitator Press Think Jim Romenesko Rough Type Gawker The Graphic Truth Tail Rank Huffington Post Instapundit Little Green Footballs Talking Points Memo MoJo Blog
Seattle Stuff
Smoking. Stuff.
|

